skip header and navigation
COGME- Council of Graduate Medical Education home page


Publications
Reports
Resource Papers

Meetings

News & Events

About COGME

Members & Staff

Useful Links

Site Index

Home


Summary of Resource Paper

The Effects of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 on Graduate Medical Education

Continued


Previous Page of Resource Paper   1   2   Page 3    

The provisions that appear to have raised the most concern are the per-hospital cap on the number of residents and the reduction in the IME adjustment factor. The cap on the number of residents discourages facilities from adding or expanding residency programs. It is an across-the-board cap that limits the total numbers of residents, but in the process, can hamper expansion of primary care specialties when hospitals do not make corresponding cuts in specialists. Although beneficial from the standpoint of curbing an oversupply of residents being trained and funded by Medicare, the limitation on primary care residents may conflict with the general goals of the Council on Graduate Medical Education (COGME) to promote the education and training of a mix of physicians consistent with current and future health care needs including in rural areas. Nevertheless, if the provisions lead to a slowdown in the growth rate of the physician workforce, while maintaining or increasing the number of primary care physicians, then the legislation is in line with COGME recommendations.2

The decreasing IME adjustment factor reduces IME payments to teaching hospitals. The IME adjustment factor is linked to the IRB ratio, which particularly affects academic health centers because they typically have the highest resident-to-bed ratios. The resulting reduction in IME payments will be offset to some extent by the Medicare "carve-out" provision, which secures a major source of GME funding for teaching facilities, by removing the GME portion of payments to managed care organizations and providing them to teaching hospitals for treating Medicare managed care enrollees. IME payments amount to approximately two-thirds of the $6.8 billion for GME paid annually by Medicare to teaching hospitals. In FY 1997 they totaled $4.6 billion.5 The changes in the calculation of IME as a result of the BBA would have resulted in a 29 percent reduction in IME funding to hospitals at the end of the five-year
phase-in period 6, *


* The full reduction in the IME payment has been delayed by two years as a result of the recent passage of the Medicare Balanced Budget Refinement Act of 1999 (BBRA). For FY2000 and FY2001, the IME adjustment factor is set at higher levels than the original BBA provided for. The full decrease still takes place in FY2002. The BBRA is discussed further on page 10.


Table 1- Medicare Payments to Hospitals and/or Ambulatory Sites, Pre and Post BBA of 1997 [D]

All hospital outpatient facilities affiliated with a hospital are paid by hospital inpatient rules.
Free standing means not hospital owned or operated.



The voluntary resident reduction program can be a windfall to hospitals that already intended to reduce their training efforts. For them the incentive payments are bonus money. For hospitals that were simply considering trimming their programs, the voluntary reduction program can be the incentive that encourages them to do it.

The BBA provides for the establishment of a consortium demonstration project. This is in alignment with a previous COGME recommendation that the federal government fund twelve consortium demonstrations. In COGME's recommendation, the projects must be committed to providing a cost-effective administrative framework within which education and workforce reform can occur.7


Previous Page of Resource Paper   1   2   Page 3    

| Publications | Meetings | News & Events | About COGME | Members & Staff | Useful Links | Site Index | Home |


Last Updated December 6, 2001

Contact Comments@hrsa.gov with site problems or comments.

Bureau of Health Professions
Health Resources & Services Administration
U.S. Dept. of Health & Human Services
U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services home page